Blogging the Neighborhood

What do blogs have to do with neighborhoods? A look at systems of ideas and the communities they create.

Creative Statement

My aim in this project is to draw a connection between blogs and neighborhoods: they are both organized around systems of ideas that are communicated in different ways in order to create particular communities. The systems of ideas that govern a blog and neighborhood are certainly different, but their deliberate structure and unity of purpose stand as common ground.

I have chosen to present my project through a blog because I have no previous experience with blogging and I believe that experiencing blogging for myself was a good way to begin to understand the community created in this sphere (although this blog is certainly different from all others in that I do not intend on updating it. Rather, I am using it as a means of presenting my information. Certainly, and unfortunately, this will limit my first-hand understanding of a blog-induced community.) I engaged with other blogs by perusing the contents of various blogs for information, commenting where the need struck, and reblogging when I found something relevant. It was interesting to interact with and present information in this way, and I felt in some way included in the blogging community by doing so (certainly more than included than I have felt in the past when I have simply viewed but not interacted with the community). Putting the information together in a specific way that suits my purposes and intention has also been interesting: I am the architect of this world, and I can understand that if anyone were to interact with me in this medium, I would feel a sense of community with them.

In contrast to true blogging fashion, I’ve ordered the posts so that they can be read top-down, and at the bottom of the page I’ve included relevant (perhaps some more so than others) blogs that I’m following.

thisbigcity:

City map by fantasy.
幻想的城市地圖。

thisbigcity:

City map by fantasy.

幻想的城市地圖。

What is a Blog?

“A blog (a blend of the term web log) a type of website or part of a website supposed to be updated with new content from time to time. Blogs are usually maintained by an individual with regular entries of commentary, descriptions of events, or other material such as graphics or video. Entries are commonly displayed in reverse-chronological order. Blog can also be used as a verb, meaning to maintain or add content to a blog.

Although not a must, most good quality blogs are interactive, allowing visitors to leave comments and even message each other via GUI widgets on the blogs and it is this interactivity that distinguishes them from other static websites. In that sense, blogging can be seen as a form of social networking. Indeed, bloggers do not only produce content to post on their blogs but also build social relations with their readers and other bloggers.” 

What is a Neighborhood?

“A neighborhood or neighborhood is a geographically localized community within a larger city, town, or suburb. Neighborhoods are often social communities with considerable face-to-face interaction among members. “Researchers have not agreed on an exact definition. Neighborhood is generally defined spatially as a specific geographic area and functionally as a set of social networks. Neighborhoods, then, are the spatial units in which face-to-face social interactions occur – the personal settings and situations where residents seek to realize common values, socialize youth, and maintain effective social control.” 

What do Neighborhoods have to do with Blogs?

What do neighborhoods have to do with blogs? I believe that a neighborhood and a blog have two important similarities: they are both organized around certain systems of ideas, which manifest in different ways to create specific communities. Systems of ideas are the principles, themes, or purposes around which a blog or a neighborhood can be organized. Ideas are communicated directly in blogs, through the chosen theme of the blog, posts, photos, links, etc. Ideas are manifested rather than spoken about in a neighborhood: the infrastructure, the ways in which culture and tradition inform the purpose of the space or how people interact, all represent the ideas with which that neighborhood was conceived and constructed. 

The community of a blog is formed without a sense of physical space or boundary and, perhaps tied to this, there is a certain anonymity in the community. A neighborhood, though bound by a physical space, still has this sense of anonymity: not everyone within a neighborhood knows one another. This raises an interesting consideration: communication in a blog community is often extensive and between many different members, but few ever communicate physically. Contrarily, members of a neighborhood can encounter each other physically without ever engaging in conversation. Both, I believe, are variations of anonymity: to know only a very limited aspect of a person impairs the formation of a holistic community, which contributes to the disparate communities created in a blog and in a neighborhood. Further, the public sphere is formed differently because members communicate differently and thus people interact differently within a neighborhood versus through a blog. 

Nothing is more common to the members of a community, in principle, than a myth, or a group of myths. Myth and community are defined by each other, at least in part – but perhaps in totality – and this motivates a reflection on the community according to myth … This reflection cannot be interrupted – indeed, in this it is unlike myth. Reflection is the resistance and the insistence of community … Their presence must be inferred, or rather what has been written under their names, intercalated here – a community unavowable because too numerous but also because it does not know itself, and does not need to know itself – intercalated, alternating, shared texts, like all texts, offering what belongs to no one and returns to everyone: the community of writing and the writing of community.

J.-L. Nancy, „The Inoperative Community“ in The Inoperative Community (U. of Minnesota Press, 1991), p 42 

On the Systems of Ideas and Community

There are many different blog sites, some of the most used being www.blogger.com, www.wordpress.com, www.livejournal.com, or www.tumblr.com, but the list is truly endless. Each blog has its own ‘feel’ or character: some are more conducive to photo blogging, others to writing, some are easier to use while others allow for more flexibility in rewriting in editing the HTML. These differences cater to different members, depending on where their interests and intentions for the blog lay. Within these blog sites, members can make blogs that generally have an overarching and uniting theme. These can be broad or specific (anywhere from ‘Spirituality’ to ‘Travel’): posts, links, photos, are cohesive and indicate the interest or inclination of the blogger.

Similarly, neighborhoods tend to be groups of like-minded individuals. Certain districts or areas within a city attract a certain type of people, who come together to form a community that bases itself on and strives toward a common understanding. Thus we can see that blogs and neighborhoods have striking similarities in the way that they form communities by uniting common interests. The metaphor might also say that blog sites represent lager areas such as cities or countries (which attract a vast range of members with varied interests, and within which form particulars).

The systems of ideas that govern blogs and neighborhoods form differently, creating different kinds of communities, with different values. In a blog, the system is given a theme that is more or less cohesive and adhered to in any posts made by the blogger. The blogger tends to create a community with other like-minded bloggers by ‘following’ them or ‘reblogging’ their posts. The ideas of the system are thus created and communicated directly, attracting like-minded individuals who can engage with the blog. There are two important interactions in this system: the other blogs that a blogger follows, and the interaction between the blogger and those that view and comment on the blog. This interaction rarely involves physical presence, and so the community is formed almost solely virtually, in a realm of words and pictures. Inherent in this system is the presence of a perpetrator, an individual who conceives of the so-called architecture of the community, and constructs it. The interaction within this community is thus very one-dimensional in that it almost always involves the blogger, and the interaction between other members is muted: there isn’t a sense of quality because this community is built on a property that is not publically owned (though it is publically accessible).

In a neighborhood, the system of ideas manifests in the infrastructure and architecture of the area, is represented by the culture and values of that community, and is present in the way people conduct themselves. The neighborhood is built up over a much more expansive time frame that reflects changing intentions, inclinations, and inhabitants. The community itself thus creates the community, unlike a blogging community, which is created by a specific individual with, presumably, a specific purpose in mind: a neighborhood directs no such responsibility on one man alone. As a result, the interactions in a neighborhood-formed community are much different: the different formations of public spheres in a neighborhood versus through a blog create environments conducive to different types of social interaction. Members of a neighborhood interact with each other more or less equally. There is no ‘higher other’ that this community caters to, and thus everyone is equally responsible for the interactions of the community: members are equally actors and audience-members. 

A blog-induced community is formed without any real sense of physical space or boundary, leading to a degree of anonymity. However, while members of a neighborhood are afforded each other’s physical presence, it is entirely possible, and probable, that many members within the community have not had any further interaction with each other: they too, in a sense, are anonymous to one another. This creates two vastly disparate communities: one where verbal communication is easy and physical encounter weighted, and another where physical encounter is casual but verbal communication is not. Neither forms a community that is holistic, for each lacks an important aspect of interaction.

Theoretical analysis must redefine the forms, functions, and structures of the city (economical, political, cultural, etc.) as well as the social needs inherent to urban society. Until now, only individual needs, their motivations marked by what is known as consumer society (the bureaucratic society of programmed consumption), have in fact been more manipulated than effectively recognized and examined. Social needs have an anthropological basis; they have opposite and complementary aspects: they include the need for security and the need for openness, the need for certainty and the need for adventure, that of the organization of labor and that of play, needs for predictability and unpredictability, for unity and difference, for isolation and encounter, for exchanges and investments, for independence (even solitude) and communication, for immediacy and long-term perspective.

H. Lefebvre, „The Right to the City“ in Ockman ed., Architecture Culture 1943-1968 (Columbia University/Rizzoli, 1993), p. 428

humanscalecities:

 
The Spirit of Cities: Why the Identity of a City Matters in a Global Age

humanscalecities:

The Spirit of Cities: Why the Identity of a City Matters in a Global Age

thisbigcity:

Ideas for cities?
「我願意和任何人討論任何事。免費!」
^^ not my comment!
(It is interesting to consider how people would respond if we brought the openness of verbal interaction, characteristic of a blog, to a city, where physical and impersonal interaction is the norm.)

thisbigcity:

Ideas for cities?

「我願意和任何人討論任何事。免費!」

^^ not my comment!

(It is interesting to consider how people would respond if we brought the openness of verbal interaction, characteristic of a blog, to a city, where physical and impersonal interaction is the norm.)

(Source: publicdesignfestival)

climateadaptation:

“Planning Cities for People
ClimateWorks is a San Francisco based foundation whose mission is to  support public policies that prevent dangerous climate change and  promote global prosperity. This document, Planning Cities for People,  was prepared for the Chinese government and contains 8 research-based  recommendations that lead to prosperous, low-carbon urban areas. The  document uses richly illustrated maps and diagrams to present examples  of street-grids that promote walking, prioritize bicycle networks,  create mixed-use neighborhoods and support high-quality transit”
Via SunFoundation
(A cool example of a community created around a specific purpose.)

climateadaptation:

“Planning Cities for People

ClimateWorks is a San Francisco based foundation whose mission is to support public policies that prevent dangerous climate change and promote global prosperity. This document, Planning Cities for People, was prepared for the Chinese government and contains 8 research-based recommendations that lead to prosperous, low-carbon urban areas. The document uses richly illustrated maps and diagrams to present examples of street-grids that promote walking, prioritize bicycle networks, create mixed-use neighborhoods and support high-quality transit”

Via SunFoundation

(A cool example of a community created around a specific purpose.)

(via humanscalecities)

Blogs I follow: